sawyer ([info]angrybonsai) wrote,
@ 2008-04-15 01:11:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
" 'When mixed-bloods, a be ta we si a ki, begin misinterpreting history and forget they are visitors,' say the Six Grandfather's Journals, 'they are an indelible part of genocide itself.'
...
Our history on occasion has had the eminence to wear a shiny coat of black feathers and soft white plumes, having absolutely no need for historians who don't even know or dare to ask their mothers the names of their fathers. "
- Ray A. Young Bear, Remnants of the First Earth (1996)

in the course of using this digital journal to chronicle the development and sundry crises in my life, i realize i have neglected to incorporate (or at least acknowledge) a much more grand narrative of context that circumscribes my day to day life in every discernable way. it is of identity, this conflict of being american indian, but also white

i am reading books by sherman alexie and ray a young bear. as you might infer from the above quote, young bear's philosophy is much more straightforward, much more confrontational than alexie's... whose stories seem to pander to the romantic delusions about american indians held by american society at large

young bear's confidence has awoken in me a skepticism that has heretofore been buried by the banality of day to day life: papers to write, deadlines, taxes, alarm clocks, midterms. this skepticism has above all things shaken my confidence in atheism, science, historiography, theory, the theory of theory and the history of "evidence"


are not all of these arguments bound by an occidental lexicon? it is challenging for me because the english language is my first language. how can i permit myself to speak in the tongue of a people who have visited a cultural genocide upon my ancestors? yes, i could quickly dismiss crimes of blood on grounds that warring tribes have committed similar violence upon each other, and these crimes are comparable to the horrors visited upon indians by the french, english, spanish et al.

but the colonialism of europeans is a new kind of malefaction that transcends time and place. colonialism is a fantastic weapon that permits the descendants of its perpetrators to wash their hands of responsibility, while the descendants of its victims still suffer. that obliteration of culture, history and language i still feel today, its absence is a phantom limb: the cause of the spiritual wandering and wasting pessimism of a people in this age.

but i am also white, so whom do i hold responsible? there is an easy answer, one that seems remotely plausible, but its ugliness makes it seem absurd: if european colonialism was a "rape" of a people, what if i am a bastard child that had the misfortune of being concieved in the act?

i feel the metaphor is far too simplistic to be practical, but this is the language i know and this is the closest i can come to describing the feeling. it alludes the emotional and culture essence of who i am.

yes, i come from a privilaged position in society: i grew up with electricity, food, running water, an education, a male, a skin color that passes as white. i am in college. you can say i live comfortably



but what i am saying is i also feel uncomfortable, because i feel i am walking upon the rotting corpses of my ancestors

and there are those who are comfortable: they are not obliged to acknowledge that horrifying carrion terrain beneath them. they are not filled with the same horror as i am, because they do not percieve this mountain of bodies as i do. because i know that those are my dead relatives, those are ashes and bones that belonged to my family, whose history, religion and language i can never fully understand because it has been taken away, and can not be given back


this is what it means to say i am a mixed-blood who mis-interprets history, to be part of the genocide


(Post a new comment)


[info]razor_zedge
2008-04-15 03:10 pm UTC (link)
Innumerable countries, civilizations, accomplishments and comfortable living situations are built over the corpses of others. To understand and respect this can make for a better world today and help assure we do not repeat the transgressions of the past. To blame those who benefit from it and could not have stopped it if they wanted to is counterproductive.

I can't pretend to understand your situation. I know I personally benefit from many deaths and horrible things, but if I spent too much time miring myself in the thought, I would never move ahead or do what I can to prevent horrible things in the future (which I feel is a legitimate concern). I could go more into depth about all this but I would feel as though I were being disingenuous as, again, I cannot hope to possibly understand how you feel here.

(Reply to this)(Thread)


[info]angrybonsai
2008-04-20 01:17 am UTC (link)
what you are saying is true, there is a vast history of violence and exploitation incomprehensible to any single person, and no matter how intensely the kinds of emotional impulses occur sometimes, the next day ill be of the mind that there is no history but for the people who are living, that there is no afterlife and the memories of the dead do not matter as everything is a chemical reaction in the brain

(Reply to this)(Parent)


[info]guitarromantic
2008-04-16 07:02 pm UTC (link)
Hmm. I agree and empathise with everything you're saying (as much as a white male of European descent can, anyway), and I think one counter to your (very accurate) description of walking on the corpses of your ancestors, is the fact that for myself, I have to live with the fact that it was my ancestors that made yours corpses in the first place. It goes both ways.

(Reply to this)


Create an Account
Forgot your login?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…